Comments on: Cylon Says – BSG: Faith

By: Hoobajoobah

Hoobajoobah — Sun, 11 May 2008 17:53:53 +0000

Yeah, I had a mad crush on the actress, and would really like to see her return in some capacity other than Apollo’s fallback girl. Is she even on the show anymore? We haven’t seen her in a month or so.

I think Billy, Dee, and Williams…uh, ‘scuse me…I think Billy, Dee, and Tigh’s Wife were being set up as Cylons all through the first half of the series’ run. I expect they had a lot of potential cylons in the show, and weren’t quite sure which ones they were gonna’ use.

By: Alpha-Girl

Alpha-Girl — Sun, 11 May 2008 00:37:56 +0000

I'd feel cheated if it turned out to be Starbuck's dad. There's an interesting theory here that Dualla is the final cylon. I'm not sure I'm in agreement, but he makes a compelling argument.

By: Mr. BoJangles

Mr. BoJangles — Sat, 10 May 2008 20:06:08 +0000

I know I’ve said this before, but I’m thinking the final one has to be Starbuck’s Dad.

If I’m wrong about that, if it *has* to be someone we’ve already met, then I’ve got nothin’.

I think the purpose of spending 2 hours on Kendra Shaw was twofold (A) to tell a story that was more-or-less self-contained so that it wouldn’t completely de-rail the storyline if your casual viewer didn’t get to see it (And a surprising number of fans haven’t seen it yet. I keep trying to get my friends to watch it, and they’re flummoxed by the concept. Is it an episode? What season is it in? Is that the Very Special One with the Fire At The Blind School? Etc.) and (B) to cover over the inconsistent and crappy way the whole Pegasus arc was handled in the first place. I mean, they only introduced the ship because it was done on the original show, but then – just like the original show – they had no idea what to do w/ the Pegasus once they had it, the crew were killed off 10 little indians-style for the sole purpose of Apollo being breveted into command (Which, let’s face it, is just damn stupid).

My hunch.