Thanks again for this wonderful review, a true gem on the internet and I’m so happy I found it. Although written a long time ago I hope you’ll see this. I hope you’ll have e nice day and keep up the good work!

Tina

You are kind to say so about this review. (Elegant? Wow!) I sometimes imagine that I’ll run out of ways to look at this show, but then I sit down to write a review, and wham, there it is. Something to write about and usually too much. Way too much.

Jensen and Jared, the boys, as well, make it a whole lot easier to watch and think. You’re right, they run the gamut of emotions in each and every ep, and they wear me out just watching them. From their eyelashes down to their toes, every muscle, every twitch. Emo, angst, pathos, humor, anger, rage…okay. Stopping there. They simply rock.

Thank you again.

Best Regards,

Sylvia

Thank you so much. I might be reading more into the eps than what’s there, but the fact is that this show gets me going there faster than anything else. I’m content to go along where it takes me, and it’s usually complicated.

As for Julie Benz, pretty doesn’t even begin to describe her. Incandescent is the perfect word for her, plus the character she played was a real woman, a real person, with dreams and wants and a history and everything good. People have gotten back to me as to how she could sit on that bed with Dean and resist him, but maybe it’s because she had more on her mind at that point. I would not have been as restrained as her, had it been me, and this further demonstrates her strength of character. I have often wondered if her will/desire to live was more on her mother’s behalf than on her own, but regardless, she was one fantastic character. Show should have more like her more often.

Best Regards,

Sylvia

You manage to find more grace and style in this show than I can remember in the watching of it. You might just convince me into liking it at this rate.

This has been, so far, my favorite episode, too, precisely for all the moral quandary. Doesn’t hurt that Julie Benz was the most fantastic foil for one of the two lead characters I’ve seen. I roll my eyes at previous guest stars who know/slept with one of the two main characters, but she really shined opposite Jensen Ackles. There’s something incandescent about their scenes that distracts even from the chemistry of the two leads.

Lovely review!

Take care of yourself.

Best Regards,

Sylvia

Coincidentally I recently re-watched this episode so it's fresh in my memory. Just wanted to say that you did a wonderful and elegant review of this episode.

This show constantly surprises me with the amazing storylines and writing. Jensen and Jared have nailed these characters and the level of emotion that they can portray…whether it's anger or sadness or just goofy brotherly affection is awesome. And they are able to usually do all 3 in a single episode.

Again..keep up the great work!

Zofia